Posted By Wasseem El Sarraj Share

GAZA CITY — A predominant, if misguided, narrative holds Gaza to be a Mediterranean secret, where food is plentiful and joy is unabated. Such statements are not exactly false. As a Gazan, I can say I have laughed, dined out (not just falafel), and been able to embrace my proclivity for consumption -- recently purchasing a 37" flat-screen TV. But this has been a product of the stubbornness and creativity of capitalism under an enforced closure (where goods flow into Gaza, but what goes out is very limited). Not to mention the sheer luck that I hail from an elite class and of the simple fact that humans, in desperate circumstances, still muster the ability to "look on the bright side of life."

Two recent developments in Gaza have propped up the "there are no problems in Gaza narrative," and will undoubtedly feature in a soon-to-be-shot promotional video by the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs.  One is the pool-hall-cum-lounge called Carrino's; the other, Munib Al-Masri's six-star Movenpick hotel.

Carrino's is straight out of Dubai. Huge LCDs line the wall, letting customers catch up on the latest episode of House MD, lemon juice costs a whopping $4, and, of course, there's a dress code. The reality is that the clientele at Carrino's is the who's who of Gaza's NGO elite.

Even more up-market than Carrino's is the Movenpick, an old investment of Munib Al-Masri, PADICO's chairman and the West Bank's richest businessman. The hotel's occupancy rate is barely in the double digits. Fortunately, its owner is a billionaire, and it's his personal fortune that keeps the lights on. For some, the Movenpick is an oasis, but for most it's a mirage; a reminder of what the majority of Gazans will never have.

I can agree with some in the Israeli establishment who say that there is an asset bubble, or something like this, in Gaza. But it will always be Israel, armed with its $8 billion laser-sighted needle that can both pop the bubble and more significantly inflate it. In the last few months, international media have reported on Gaza's relative peace and calm. Gazans are counting themselves lucky that Israel has all but stopped its military incursions. No air strikes, no drones, no early morning beach shelling or the rare sonic boom.

In the last two weeks, however, Israel predictably responded to rockets fired from Gaza. It takes literally seconds for Gazans to be reminded who is really in control -- whether it's at the Rafah border, where Gazans' fate is decided by incompetent Egyptian border officers, or perhaps on the coast where fishermen are told by the Israeli navy where and when they can catch their living. The agency of most Gazans is reduced to which football team they choose to support. For the luckier ones, an evening at Carrino's or Movenpick offers some respite.

Yet the majority of Gazans are dependent on Israeli products: many supermarkets in Gaza are stocked with Oreos, Magnum Ice Creams, and kosher milk and butter. As such, the possibility of a Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions campaign is hindered by Israel's monopoly of the market and compounded by the dearth of competition from Palestinian producers. In fact, when Gazans (some, though not all) are not being tempted by delicious snacks, they are shopping in the mall. It is almost counterintuitive to think that the alleged creation of an army of modern consumers in Gaza runs opposite to Israeli interests. What better a population to do business with than a population paying homage to malls and not Mecca?

Instead, Israel chooses to instrumentalize this modicum of normality -- albeit for a minority -- in order to conceal its occupation of the territory. International media outlets often tow this line. Popular media narratives often depict positive and incremental changes in Gaza, though always glossing over the fact that Israel has been an occupying power for over six decades. The removal of this historical context leaves readers wondering what all the fuss is about. Why send boats to Gaza? They have pizza, don't they? Why do those "barbarians" insist on firing rockets? They have a pretty beach and a calming sunset.  The common meme has become that Gazans must learn to be more grateful.

A prominent Western journalist recently visited Gaza. During his meeting with young bloggers, which I attended, he took the opportunity to tell us that Gaza is not in as bad shape as Haiti. He is right; Gaza is not a humanitarian disaster on the scale of Haiti, nor is it famine-stricken like Somalia. But the issue, as one of the sharp young bloggers pointed out, is that Haiti was shaken by an earthquake; the tragedy of Gaza is man-made.

This man-made tragedy has put Gaza on a devastating trajectory. Natural water supplies are predicted to evaporate; only five percent of the wells in Gaza produce water that meets World Health Organization drinking water standards. Fifty-six thousand cubic liters of sewage pour into the sea each day. Gaza's export industry is practically non-existent.

Most of Gaza's factories were destroyed by Israel during its 2009 invasion, and Israel refuses to allow a normal flow of export goods. One exception, however, is a company that exports catchy ring-tones to the Gulf.

Education has also suffered. According to UNESCO, seven universities were damaged during the 2009 invasion, and six buildings were destroyed (and Israel has permitted few reconstruction materials to enter Gaza since). The same report highlights the lack of optimism amongst university students as 71 percent are not hopeful about their future and are very concerned by the prospect of another war. All of these issues will persist and worsen, as long as Israel allows them to do so. What will remain relatively untouched are the tiny pockets of wealth that will always exist in Gaza.

Israel has been able to strategically extricate itself from the Gaza Strip. It has the international community all but convinced that the territory's problems are Gazans' own fault. Hamas's arrival was almost too good to be true. What better a fall guy than incompetent religious fundamentalists? In the midst of the Arab-Spring, Egypt (which under Mubarak had been complicit -- and at times encouraging -- of Gaza's closure) must now answer to the Palestinians, a revitalized Egyptian population, and global activists.

Meanwhile, Israel stands back as a community teeters on the brink of humanitarian disaster. Israel's unwillingness to significantly, and sustainably, improve the situation in the Gaza Strip has created a dead zone both economically and intellectually. It does not take an expert to predict that a more virulent form of fundamentalist ideology will continue to ferment.

Israel has failed to engage with the very Palestinians who spend afternoons in the shopping mall and evenings at Movenpick. All of this begs the question: what sort of Palestinians does Israel intend to make peace with?

Wasseem El Sarraj is a researcher with the Gaza-based think tank TiDA.

AFP/Getty images

 

SG

5:26 PM ET

July 28, 2011

Facts?

There are various statements in this article that are factually untrue. Take, for example: "Popular media narratives often depict positive and incremental changes in Gaza, though always glossing over the fact that Israel has been an occupying power for over six decades."

Truth: Israel has only been involved in Gaza since 1967.

 

BUDAHH

5:41 AM ET

July 29, 2011

Short memory loss of things that led to the situation today.

What has stopped the palestinian people from creating a Singapore when Israel had left the gaza strip, in 2005 the passages were completely open, there was a free flow of goods and a free outflow of goods.

Why did you not build those Universities you were talking about than, Israel supplies gaza with water and electricity you kind of forgot to mention that, I am sure that it slipped your mind,

Israel also has responsibility for what happens in gaza, yet you forgot to blame one important player, the hamas has brought nothing but misery to gaza, if they would have not been shooting at the passages they would still be open today, you cannot just tell the end story and not say what led to it.
If the hamas cared about its people it would use its money to build universities and improve the economy, how can you only lay the blame on Israel when the governmnt in gaza swears that its main purpose is destroying Israel and not making it's citizens lives better,

I truely feel for the normal gazan people who just want to make a living and have a better life for them and for their kids, yet the main player to be blamed here is hamas, I am sure that any other country in the world would react a lot worse than Israel does, think how do you deal with that situation when your enemy is stockpiling rockets to shoot at your civilians and declaring he wants to destroy you, it is not an easy situation and unfortunately some good people have to suffer, you should be writing this letter to the IRanian government telling them that they should stop sending money to hamas and interfering in your affairs, or to the U.E telling them to pressure hamas to change its ways,

 

JOHNWV

6:06 AM ET

July 29, 2011

PUNITIVE REPARATIONS

Israel has reduced Gaza to an open air prison and collectively tortures and kills its inmates by merely denying necessities. The Jewish State’s cruel abuse of their goyim inferiors is on vivid display to the whole world. Peaceful flotilla, diplomacy or violence, anything that can be done to extricate the Israeli occupiers of Palestine is justified and commendable. May the contiguous and fully autonomous Palestinian State be recognized and thrive on PUNITIVE REPARATIONS so debilitating that Israel’s very existence is justly threatened.

 

JOHNWV

3:06 PM ET

July 31, 2011

Reply to NEOLEFTT

Palestinian Gaza is besieged and occupied by the supremacis­t theocracy/ethnocracy Israel has made of itself. To Israelis, Palestinians are goyim, inferior and subhuman. They are incarcerated, tortured, killed and otherwise abused by their Jewish occupiers. Could you, poor Neoleftt, joyously thrive under such masters?

 

IDIOTPRAYER84

7:23 PM ET

July 29, 2011

Hamas and Israel playing off each other

How can a nation build a modern economy if it can't import or export anything? In order to take advantage of comparative advantage and have a competitive economy, a country can't produce all the goods needed within its borders. The Gaza blockaded has caused the price of everything to sky rocket and has crippled Palestinians who want to build businesses instead of bombs.The only people who has benefited from the blockaded is Hamas. The reason that Hamas shoots rockets into Israel is to provoke Israel to retaliate and kill civilians. The outrage caused covers up the fact that Hamas has no plan to either create a free Palestinian state or build a functioning economy. If Israel would have left Gaza alone and let Hamas show how incompetent they are at providing basic services and improving the lives of the people in the Gaza Strip. Israel chose the short sighted strategy of the Gaza blockade which helps Hamas, undercuts moderates who want peace and makes Palestinians more dependent on states that want to use the Palestinian state issue to take the focus away from their own failures.

 

JOHNWV

7:21 AM ET

July 30, 2011

...if only the IDF would tell their parents where they are.

Corporal Gilad Shalit was a soldier in uniform, on duty and armed when taken prisoner. Reporting his having been "kidnapped" is typical of Israel's engineered news and its propagation by Jewish biased media. Yes, his detention is tragic, but less so than the detention of each of the children as young as thirteen among Israel's 11,000 Palestinian prisoners. I suspect they mostly just want to see their parents again; if only the Israeli Army would tell their parents where they are.

 

JOHNWV

2:25 PM ET

July 31, 2011

Reply to NEOLEFTT

Hamas is a legitimately elected government besieged by, and at war with, Israel. But please ask yourself Neoleftt, what would happen if Hamas disclosed Corporal Shalit's location. Right, the Jewish State would quickly overwhelm and probably kill his captors. The Israel vs. occupied Palestine war is an asymmetric war and international rules of warfare don't work when the opponents are way mismatched. Are you sure about denial of medical treatment, and decent living conditions?

 

IDIOTPRAYER84

5:40 PM ET

July 30, 2011

Israel stummbling over the same rock over and over

That is the reason Hamas does stuff like kidnappings and suicide bombings. Why do you think that terrorist violence increases when peace talks are taking place? They want to sabotage peace because without the occupation and the suffering of the Palestinian people they're irrelevant. That is why Hamas sees Salam Fayyad as such a threat. If the Palestinian Territories are peaceful and prosperous, Hamas' funding drys up and losses public support.

Hezbollah does the same thing. Why do you think the rocket attack increased after the assassination of Rafik Hariri and Israel's withdrawal from Lebanon? Everybody knew Hezbollah and Syria were behind it and Syria had to pull out. The rocket attacks provoked Israel and gave legitimacy to a Hezbollah that was on the ropes. Saad Hariri's looked week and Hezbollah had major gains. Now that Bashir al-Assad is in trouble and the region is turning on Iran, Hezbollah is trying to provoke another attack and Israel is talking about another attack. If Israel thought a few steps ahead, they would realize that its playing into the hands of their enemies.

 

IDIOTPRAYER84

7:24 PM ET

August 1, 2011

Hamas on the ropes

Peace and economic development undercut Hamas. As it is, the people in Gaza have turned on the Hamas led government. The people in Gaza care about jobs while Hamas is trying to enforce Taliban style laws. For all its flaws, Fatah is benefiting from Hamas' heavy hand and hopefully Fatah can take advantage. Its easy for radical groups to sit on the sideline and complain. Now that Hamas is in power in Gaza, they're finding out that they now have responsibilities to fulfill they're struggling to meet people's basic needs. Hamas is undermining itself by its own incompetence. The only thing that might save Hamas is another invasion by Israel.

 

GROVER LAHMANN

3:06 AM ET

August 19, 2011

Gaza’s economic mirage

Restricted access remains the main factor limiting economic growth. Sporadic closures and unstable political conditions in the West Bank continue to disrupt work and curtail productivity.Restrictions on access and movement in the West Bank, including tera patrick East Jerusalem, include the separation wall, checkpoints and other physical obstacles, together with an increasingly sophisticated permit system. The number of checkpoints and physical obstructions climbed above 620 during the year 2009, according to the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA). These impediments continue to choke economic activity and damage the social fabric, along with the well-being of the population.Israeli efforts to reduce the number of Palestinians living and working in East Jerusalem are steadily isolating it from the rest of the West Bank. The Arab inhabitants of East Jerusalem face multiple forms of discrimination. In Israel as a whole, unemployment is much higher among Arab citizens, and discontent has been growing. A recent survey by the University of Haifa revealed that 48% of Israel's Arab citizens are dissatisfied with their lives in the Jewish State, compared to 35% in 2003. One factor has been the Israeli Government’s announcement that it will continue with the expansion of settlements in East Jerusalem, despite the protests of civil society organizations.

 

AXELBROOK

6:25 AM ET

August 19, 2011

he majored in poly sci with

he majored in poly sci with an emphasis in international relations. thats essentially nothing but at least hes educated on the subject. id rather have someone with a degree involving foreign relations than someone who took 6 years to get a degree in journalism and hadnt been outside of the US and canada until a few months before she ran for vp. and even when she left the country she only went to military bases, so that barely counts. oh yeah, and obama was on the senate foreign relations committee. thats notnothing. RIO he helped negotiate a weapons treaty in Russia, Ukraine, and Azerbaijan, he went to jordan, israel, and palestine to discuss middle east relations, and went to South Africa, Kenya, Djibouti, Ethiopia and Chad to discuss corruption and ethnic rivalries..

 

The Middle East Channel offers unique analysis and insights on this diverse and vital region of more than 400 million.

Read More

Enter your email address to get twice-weekly updates from the Mideast Channel:

Delivered by Constant Contact