Posted By Salman Shaikh Share

While US and international attention is focused largely elsewhere in the region, especially Libya, the violent crackdown against protestors in the tiny island kingdom of Bahrain may well pose a bigger threat to the entire region's stability. The Bahrain situation is exposing long simmering tensions and rivalries between Saudi Arabia and Iran and carries the danger that it will trigger the next regional war. Such a scenario would likely draw in the United States at a time when its relationships with key allies in the region, especially Saudi Arabia, are under strain. Urgent action is therefore needed to de-escalate the situation in Bahrain and create the trust necessary for the government and opposition to start a much delayed national dialogue that charts the future of the country.

Worryingly, a senior unidentified Saudi official has described the mission of Saudi and other GCC troops to support the Bahraini security forces as "open-ended." A three month state of emergency has led to a campaign of house raids and arrests that have included the leaders of the main opposition parties, as well as human rights activists and other dissidents. There are also mounting concerns that these combined security forces are using disproportionate force and committing serious violations of international law and humanitarian law. The space for dialogue seems to be rapidly closing.

In the days ahead, we are likely to see a deepening of the culture of resistance in Bahrain. In particular, calls for dialogue to establish a constitutional monarchy may be swept away by more radical groups and the combative youth that increasingly supports them. Further radicalization of Bahrainis seems inevitable the longer the current impasse lasts, carrying with it the real danger that the country will be mired in a full blown civil war.



King Hamad bin Isa Al-Khalifa's invitation of the GCC forces has also posed new dilemmas and real dangers for the Gulf and the wider Middle East. It is a crisis which is assuming worrying regional and sectarian dimensions. If the Tunisian revolt was the springboard for the revolution in Egypt and it's catalytic effect on the peoples of the region, the crisis in Bahrain signals the first battle in the shaping of the new Middle East. Instead of the focus being on the people's revolts for dignity, justice, and greater democratic representation that are transforming the region, we are slipping back in to the old narratives that so dominated the region over the past two decades.

These decades were defined by three main narratives: the struggle between western-backed "moderates" and Iranian and Syrian backed "militants" such as Hamas and Hezbollah; the fight against Islamic extremism, particularly Al-Qaeda and the "war on terror" following September 11; and the growing mistrust between Shias and Sunnis, especially following the ouster of Saddam Hussein in Iraq. On top of these dynamics, the total failure of Israeli-Palestinian peace efforts and concern for Iran's nuclear ambitions have led many to predict that the region is heading towards war.

In the midst of the Arab peoples' awakenings of 2011, the Bahrain crisis has once again raised these specters. The result may be the transformation of the existing Saudi-Iranian "Cold War" to direct confrontations and the intensification of "proxy conflicts," already prevalent in the region.

For its part, the Iranian regime has responded swiftly to events in Bahrain, calling the GCC move an "occupation" and an "invasion" even as it continues to crush its own people's Green Revolution. As the situation in Bahrain deteriorates, Iran may seek creative ways to interfere, perhaps by using its proxies in Lebanon or Iraq. Iraq, Lebanon, and Hamas-led Gaza provide examples of Iran's ability to capitalize on chaos and conflict to further its interests in the region.

Worryingly, on Saturday, the Basij militia is reported to have attacked the Saudi consulate in the northern Iranian town of Mashhad. The Hezbollah chief also weighed in on Saturday by likening the Khalifa family to the Mubarak or Gaddafi families and called on his Bahrain "brothers to resist in defending your rights." He also added for good measure that "your blood and wounds will defeat the tyrants." The Bahrain government reacted angrily, called Nasrallah's speech a "terrorist speech" and warned the Lebanese government that it would hold it responsible for such statements "which would undoubtedly impact on bilateral relations."

The situation in Bahrain may well be providing Iran the opportunity to influence the emerging new regional order, which it has not been instrumental in creating or shaping till now.

The Bahrain crisis is also showing the limits of U.S. influence and power in a region vital to American interests. The Obama administration's calls to speed up political reforms and its more recent condemnation of the crackdown have fallen on deaf ears in Manama. Instead, King Hamad has sought counsel or been influenced by Bahrain's big brother, Saudi Arabia. For their part, the Saudis, increasingly upset with Washington, have warned both the United States and Iran not to interfere in Bahrain's affairs. We really are in unchartered territory.

Bahrain represents the clearest indication of a rupture in Saudi-US relations. As both struggle to manage the sweeping changes in the region, they seem to be on starkly different paths. Saudi Arabia, in particular, may have already determined that the US, especially President Obama, cannot be relied upon to safeguard well-established mutual interests in the region, including the protection of the Kingdom and the House of Saud itself. If this is the case, U.S. influence on Saudi Arabia may be nose-diving at a time when it is most needed. As the region enters a period of prolonged instability, increasingly sharp disagreements between the United States and Saudi Arabia may well be the biggest casualty of the Bahrain crisis.

This could result in Saudi ambivalence about raising its own output to keeping oil prices down -- something which would have a direct effect on gas prices in the US and internationally. More notably, Saudi leadership may make the GCC less reliant on US leadership and diminish further US influence and power in the region. Nevertheless, the United States, Europe, and others in the region must not falter in their calls to end the crackdown and pursue a political solution to the Bahrain crisis. Only a political solution can halt Bahrain's slide to civil war and avert a greater regional fallout.

The path to such a solution can be achieved in two steps: firstly by establishing a truce based on the ending of opposition protests, the release of all opposition leaders and activists, and the withdrawal from Bahrain of all GCC forces. Secondly, a time-bound national dialogue of two months should be possible based on the principles of enhancing political representation and accountability and the sharing of power. This dialogue should also serve as the basis for talks aimed at achieving the far-reaching goal of a "constitutional or parliamentary monarchy" in the country. It is a goal that King Hamad has previously set and which the mainstream opposition parties are demanding. It is now time to put aside sectarian concerns and deep seated existential fears and get on with the job of achieving this for the future of Bahrain, the Gulf region, and the entire Middle East. 

Salman Shaikh is Director of the Brookings Institution's Doha Center and Fellow at the Saban Center for Middle East Policy. Shaikh previously served as the Special Assistant for the Middle East and Asia to the United Nations Under-Secretary-General for Political Affairs and as an adviser to former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan. 

AFP/Getty images

 

MGHULOUM

12:23 PM ET

March 23, 2011

A Solution for Bahrain? Forget About It…….

A reasonable idea, but it is not gonna happen. A constitutional monarchy is exactly what the Saudis, and their Emirati sidekicks, went into Bahrain to prevent. The opposition wants this type of solution, had called for it (in spite of some noisy emotional and unrealistic minority demands that are being exploited by the regime and its Salafi allies around the Gulf). There is also a hardline wing of the al-Khalifa clan that wants a Saudi style absolute monarchy or the closest thing to it.
(more on my posting)

 

ESTHER HAMAN

2:45 PM ET

March 23, 2011

Saudi Design in Persian Gulf

Bahrain will be free and the shoe will be on th eother foot for the Saudis. What is the 911 culprit, the House of Saud going to do about this little the upheaval In Yemen now? Send in more troops and army into Yemen as they did with Bahrain to try to save their own fat behind and to stay on the throne a bit longer?! OOH and of course We in the US will support them, so they can buy some more of our highly effective weapons and keep our Military Industrial Complex well oiled. A Democracy like us just can't get any better. Mo money Mo money.

 

FELINE74

1:34 AM ET

March 24, 2011

One way to push Bahrain in this direction.

Arrange for all of our military personnel and equipment in places that are participating in the occupation to be transferred to parts of the Gulf that aren't. Once they realize they've been left open to an Iranian attack, the Khalifas might be more inclined to listen.

 

AHMEDRADHI

4:41 AM ET

March 24, 2011

What Bahrainies Wants

Justice as the for our lost
equality as we have been denied for the last 230 years
freedom as we deserve as human being to say and vote
Democracy to have our rights and dignity maintained

those are noble basic human rights values no one on this earth disagree with us in bahrain, Apart from Saudi king, Bahraini King, UAE king, Oman King, Kuwaiti king and Qatari King thsoe belong to dark ages dictators and i think everybody agrees with us in Bahrain and with people across the Gulf as a whole.

we as Bahrainies, are able to determine our fate and destiny for ourselves and our coming generation based on the respect and the maintainance of those basic human rights values, we can share amongst us in Bahrain.

we understand our startegic and critcal geographical location, and the situation we are in at our past and present sequeezed between big brothers Saudi, Iranian, USA, UK, West, and Iraq as new major player just to north of our water, and share with us more bloods Arab and shia than iranian shia only.

We also have our own indentity as Bahrainies liberal and democartic forces with a long history fot more than 50 years struggle for Democarcy and human right values for all Bahrainies. As we have raised our demand on 1923 and 1938, 1952, 1956, 1965, 1971, 1976, 1981, 1988, 1994, 1996, 2001, 2008, 2010, and 2011.

all the accusation set against us at those past struggle for freedom were trying to over through Government by voilent means. in all of the past freedom struggle of Bahraini people turning points apart from the 1981, both shiit and sunnies were the leaders of the movement, including the present uprising as the first speaker to be detained and the first political leader detained were sunnies, and the majority of the detainees are shiit as proportional representation of the Bahrain population 70% shiit. But the recent political detaineed the first was Mohd albufalsa and the first political leader arrested after the storm of the protesters by the saudi forces is Ebrahim sharif they both sunnies.

we all have our agreements and differences with Iran regime and as democratic liberal forces of bahrain we have more disgreement than agreement with iran regime and ofcourse i personally and many of us are supporter of the demoratic movement in iran and for the real democarcy in siyria and we understand the call for those two regimes respect human rights and to allow people of their country to have justice, equality, freedom, democracy adn live in the 21st century.

we also llok forward to have those democratic movement and population of those countries to support our Bahraini struggle for freedom.

We also have all the right to ask the people of the US and UK and all civilized and free world to support our freedom struggle in Bahrain.

and we ahve all the right peacefully to ask the USA admin, and UK government to immediately stop the support of the dark ages dictatorshipes in Bahrain and every where in Gulf and arround the glob. and to say the truth to their voters about their support to gadafi and business deals done with him for the last 10 years, for the sake of dirty business money, examples are very clear UK government and the release of the libyan killer under the pretext of Cancer, and then went in to sign OIl deal, and ALYAMAMAH deal with dark ages dictatorships in saudi and how the labour govermnet stopped the UK court from further investigating the curroption behined it, the UK public deserve to see the truth and the total truth.

we in Bahrain will be standing with oir principals and basic human right values for everybody in Bahrain. we are standing firm and willing to Die for it, we ahve paid the price and we know there might be a nasty turning ahead, put we no we have to sort our struggle and stand as equal people building out country and our future generations getting the dark ages dictatorshipes out of our way once and for all. with help of the free people and peace loving nations in UK, USA, Europe, Japan, every where and every corner of this world we will reach them make them understand our fair and civilised rights and we will win. At this point of time we also ask the USA and UK goverment to take their moral responsiblities and stop and ask their friends the dark ages dictators of bahrain and Wahabies who kiiled the american in New york to stop killing people of bahrain and to respect our right of expression.as basic human rights values and to ask the Saudi wahabies armies out of our country befoer we do it ourselves, by that time it will be to late for the american and the british as they stay ignorants at the moment to blame us to refuse to die as nation.

 

ESTHER HAMAN

10:45 AM ET

March 24, 2011

US Design in Pesian Gulf

The invasion of Bahrain occurred only several hours after our Secretary Robert Gate visited that Island and organized our Stooges in Saudi Arabia to send in the troops to save these Wahabi Fascists.

Bahrain will NOT be the same after this and These Wahabi tyrants time is UP.

Free Bahrain.

 

The Middle East Channel offers unique analysis and insights on this diverse and vital region of more than 400 million.

Read More

Enter your email address to get twice-weekly updates from the Mideast Channel:

Delivered by Constant Contact