Posted By Sasha Polakow-Suransky Share

The Israeli government has it in for Richard Goldstone. Ever since Goldstone, a Jewish South African judge, issued a report in September charging Israel (and Hamas) with war crimes during the January 2009 invasion of Gaza, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has attacked him -- and his report -- as a grave threat to Israel's legitimacy.

On Thursday, leading Israeli government officials escalated their campaign against Goldstone, accusing him of sending 28 black South Africans to their deaths while serving as a judge during the apartheid years.

"The judge who sentenced black people to death … is a man of double standards," Knesset Speaker Reuven Rivlin proclaimed. "Such a person should not be allowed to lecture a democratic state defending itself against terrorists." Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon insisted, "This so-called respected judge is using this report in order to atone for his sins," likening Goldstone's statement that he was forced to uphold the laws of an unjust regime to "explanations we heard in Nazi Germany after World War II."

And the newspaper Yediot Ahronoth declared breathlessly -- with nods of approval from Jeffrey Goldberg and Jonathan Chait -- that "the man who authored the Goldstone report criticizing the IDF's actions during Operation Cast Lead took an active part in the racist policies of one of the cruelest regimes of the 20th century."

So did Israel's government.

Goldstone's apartheid-era judicial rulings are undoubtedly a blot on his record, but his critics never mention the crucial part he played in shepherding South Africa through its democratic transition and warding off violent threats to a peaceful transfer of power -- a role that led Nelson Mandela to embrace him and appoint him to the country's highest court.

More importantly, Ayalon's and Rivlin's moralism conveniently ignores Israel's history of arming the apartheid regime from the mid-1970s until the early 1990s. By serving as South Africa's primary and most reliable arms supplier during a period of violent internal repression and external aggression, Israel's government did far more to aid the apartheid regime than Goldstone ever did.

The Israel-South Africa alliance began in earnest in April 1975 when then-Defense Minister Shimon Peres signed a secret security pact with his South African counterpart, P.W. Botha. Within months, the two countries were doing a brisk trade, closing arms deals totaling almost $200 million; Peres even offered to sell Pretoria nuclear-capable Jericho missiles. By 1979, South Africa had become the Israeli defense industry's single largest customer, accounting for 35 percent of military exports and dwarfing other clients such as Argentina, Chile, Singapore, and Zaire.

High-level exchanges of military personnel soon followed. South Africans joined the Israeli chief of staff in March 1979 for the top-secret test of a new missile system. During Israel's 1982 invasion of Lebanon, the Israeli army took South African Defense Force chief Constand Viljoen and his colleagues to the front lines, and Viljoen routinely flew visiting Israeli military advisors and embassy attachés to the battlefield in Angola where his troops were battling Angolan and Cuban forces.

There was nuclear cooperation, too: South Africa provided Israel with yellowcake uranium while dozens of Israelis came to South Africa in 1984 with code names and cover stories to work on Pretoria's nuclear missile program at South Africa's secret Overberg testing range. By this time, South Africa's alternative sources for arms had largely dried up because the United States and European countries had begun abiding by the U.N. arms embargo; Israel unapologetically continued to violate it.

The blatant hypocrisy of the latest attack on Goldstone is nothing new. In November 1986, Benjamin Netanyahu, then Israel's U.N. ambassador, gave a stirring speech to the General Assembly denouncing apartheid and insisting that "Arab oil producers provide the umbilical cord that nourishes the apartheid regime." (Never mind that Israel remained absent from the 1980 U.N. vote to impose an oil embargo on South Africa in deference to its friends in Pretoria.)

Netanyahu was right that Arab and Iranian oil was flowing through middlemen to the apartheid regime, but he categorically denied Israel's extensive military and trade ties with South Africa, calling charges of lucrative arms sales "flat nonsense" and accusing his critics of trying "to defame Israel."

In fact, Israel was profiting handsomely from selling weapons to Pretoria at the time. Writing in the New York Times, Thomas Friedman estimated that the two countries did $400 mllion to $800 million of business in the arms sector in 1986. According to declassified South African documents, the figure was likely even greater: A single contract for modernization of South African fighter jets in the mid-1980s amounted to "approximately $2 billion," and  arms sales in 1988 -- one year after Israel imposed sanctions against the apartheid regime -- exceeded $1.5 billion. As the former head of the South African Air Force Jan van Loggerenberg told me bluntly: "Israel was probably our only avenue in the 1980s."

Declassified South African arms-procurement figures (which exclude lucrative cooperative ventures and shared financing arrangements) reveal the full extent of Netanyahu's lie. The "independent IMF figures" he cited (which excluded diamonds and arms) suggested trade was a minuscule $100 million annually. It was actually between five to 10 times that amount -- depending on the year -- making the apartheid regime Israel's second- or third-largest trading partner after the United States. Not all of the weapons Israel sold were used in external wars, and there is no denying that Israeli arms helped prolong the rule of an immoral and racist regime.

Before casting stones from their glass house, Ayalon, Rivlin, and Israeli journalists would do well to examine -- and acknowledge -- their government's own shameful history of collaboration with the apartheid regime.

Sasha Polakow-Suransky is a senior editor at Foreign Affairs and author of The Unspoken Alliance: Israel's Secret Relationship with Apartheid South Africa.

Sign up here to receive the Middle East Channel's twice-weekly brief in your inbox, and follow the Middle East Channel on Twitter. 

AFP/Getty Images

 

LAL QILA

1:12 AM ET

May 11, 2010

We love Goldstone for telling the truth for a change

We love Goldstone for telling the truth for a change in this world so manipulated by the Weird Jews of Israel who call themselves Zionists.

Thank you, thank you, thank you.

South African Jews threatened to disrupt the religious ceremony of the grandson of Justice Richard Goldstone – Thin skinned Jews calling everybody an anti-Semite.

Read more here: http://lalqila.wordpress.com/2010/04/28/south-african-jews-threatened-to-disrupt-the-religious-ceremony-of-the-grandson-of-justice-richard-goldstone-thin-skinned-jews-calling-everybody-an-anti-semite/

 

JCPAJERUSALEMCENTER

6:46 AM ET

May 11, 2010

get the real story

Want the real story on Justice Goldstone and the report? Check out these resources from the Jerusalem Center:

"New Revelations About the UN Goldstone Report that Seriously Undermine its Credibility" by Dore Gold and Lt. Col. (ret.) Jonathan D. Halevi, http://www.jcpa.org/JCPA/Templates/ShowPage.asp?DRIT=0&DBID=1&LNGID=1&TMID=111&FID=378&PID=1857&IID=3377&TTL=New_Revelations_About_the_UN_Goldstone_Report_that_Seriously_Undermine_its_Credibility

Amb. Dore Gold's Presentation at Brandeis University, http://jcpa.org/JCPA/Templates/ShowPage.asp?DBID=1&LNGID=1&TMID=722&FID=795

The Challenge of the UN Gaza Report, http://jcpa.org/JCPA/Templates/ShowPage.asp?DBID=1&LNGID=1&TMID=111&FID=254&PID=0&IID=3123

 

BETZ55

11:41 AM ET

May 11, 2010

transtrist -

Rocket attacks from Gaza have almost ceased. A small number of rockets have been fired, although splinter groups and not Hamas itself are believed to be behind the attacks.

While the rockets are an ineffective means of fighting back, they are the logical outcome of over sixty years of brutality, ethnic cleansing and assorted crimes against humanity committed by Israel against the Palestinians and other Arabs neighbors.

You want an end to the 'rocket' attacks? End the occupation, declare borders, and make peace.

The same cannot be said of the illegal settler terrorists who continue to burn and deface mosque's, just like the Nazi's. Burn fields, and cut down olive trees, beat up Palestinains, deny them water, and illegally squat in Palestinian homes.

Whenever a native population is abuses by colonists, there WILL be resistance. Period.

 

BETZ55

1:51 PM ET

May 11, 2010

Nonsense

The Goldstone Report also itemizes the crimes of Hamas, notably in its campaign of rocket-firing into Israel.

But the scale of human rights abuses by Israel vastly outdoes anything Hamas could hope to have achieved: Israeli civilian victims of Hamas rocket attacks numbered less than ten.

The attack on Gaza by the IDF resulted in at least 1,100 Palestinian civilian deaths. The major perpetrator of human rights abuses in this conflict is without question Israel.

 

DMOLONEY

6:49 AM ET

May 11, 2010

Pro-likudniks really are

Pro-likudniks really are grasping at straws at this stage, the gaza war was completely pointless, according to Yuval Diskin, the head of the Israeli security services Shin Bet at the time Hamas was interested in continuing the truce, yet israel was not and because of this hundreds of innocent people were killed.
If the likes of goldberg were intersted in whats best for israel he should invest more time offering constructive criticism instead of offering knee-jerk support to wrong-headed israeli policies and also stop with his knee-jerk criticism of those who fairly point out israels faults like goldstone.

 

DMOLONEY

11:04 AM ET

May 11, 2010

The Gaza war was fought by

The Gaza war was fought by Kadima-Labour coalition, of which the Labour leader Ehud Barak had retained his post as Defense Minister in Netanyahu's government. Learn.

I never claimed that the likud party was in power during the war, i used the term likudnik to describe those with aggressive and self-defeating pro-israeli views who are weakly attempting to discredit goldstone and his findings

 

DMOLONEY

9:47 AM ET

May 12, 2010

Becaue, just as Obama, you

Becaue, just as Obama, you understand nothing about Israel and you don't think you need to - your hate for Jews is enough for you.

Its a bit extreme to believe that im anti-jewish just because im critical of certain israeli actions, quite frankly i think that you should be embarressed to state such a foolish thing

 

DNOMORE

10:56 AM ET

May 12, 2010

Because, just as Obama, you understand nothing

"Becaue, just as Obama, you understand nothing about Israel and you don't think you need to"

Hey, you don't need to deal with us no-nothings anymore. Just stop accepting welfare from us. Stop sending beggers into our Synagogues during high holidays begging us to buy Israel bonds. Break away, become independent, and you can feel free to do as you please. Until then, you're suboordinating yourselves to us no-nothings.

Unfortunately, we do think we need to know something about Israel.

 

NSC LONDON

8:38 AM ET

May 11, 2010

Yet another Israel-bashing article from FP

Ah yes, the Goldstone Report, sponsored by the Arab League and the , a bastion of impartiality and credibility.

This kind of obfuscation is amusing to read. It is doubly amusing when you contrast the cacophony of criticism for Israel’s many so-called “human rights abuses” to the deafening silence around the issue of Hamas’ human rights abuses. Let’s see here, they include, using human shields, bombing civilian locations, using child soldiers, and last but not least, promoting the many barbarisms that are part and parcel of the Islamic world (female circumcision, burkas and the like).

It’s also worth pointing out that the evidence, as Goldstone stated, was based almost entirely on UNVERIFIABLE PALESTINIAN CLAIMS AND PUBLICATIONS FROM POLITICIZED PRO-PALESTINIAN NGOS – THE REPORT CITES B'TSELEM AND THE PALESTINIAN CENTER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS EACH MORE THAN 70 TIMES, AL-HAQ ALLEGATIONS GET MORE 30 MENTIONS, AND THERE ARE MANY MORE NGO CO-AUTHORS (a shout out to Israel Against Terror for those factoids).

So, if you guys aren’t going to play fair then I guess I have no recourse but to accuse you of anti-Semitism. That goes for Mr. Goldstone himself, a self-hating Jew is the worst type of anti-Semite.

 

LAL QILA

10:27 AM ET

May 11, 2010

UK Jewish MP: Israel acting like Nazis in Gaza

UK Jewish MP: Israel acting like Nazis in Gaza

See for yourself: http://lalqila.wordpress.com/2010/04/29/uk-jewish-mp-israel-acting-like-nazis-in-gaza/

 

ZUHOFEN

11:44 AM ET

May 11, 2010

Anti--Semitism

Ah, yes, another example of the poverty of effective and factual rebuttal by the Pro-Israel-Can-Do-Nothing-Wrong-Faction. When all else fails, accuse the opposition of unfair play and label them as ethnic hate-mongers.

Try using it on a group of freshman high school students, and you may get an occasional rise. For the rest of us, it is a boring, pathetic, and lazy response that serves only to confirm the legitimacy of what it is dredged up to attack.

 

BETZ55

11:50 AM ET

May 11, 2010

Ridiculous

Israel’s many so-called “human rights abuses” to the deafening silence around the issue of Hamas’ human rights abuses. Let’s see here, they include, using human shields, bombing civilian locations, using child soldiers, and last but not least, promoting the many barbarisms that are part and parcel of the Islamic world (female circumcision, burkas and the like).

So called? The human rights abuse is real and factual, not, 'so-called'. No one believes your hogwash habara. All that that you accuse Hamas of doing, Israel has done and worse. Let's see, in Gaza, Israel used human shields, bombed civilian locations ( the UN building was a biggie ), using child soldiers ( mandatory for Israeli's ), and promoting barbarisms that are part and parcel of the Jewish world ( burning Islamic mosques, beating up Palestinans farmers, burning land and cutting down olive trees, illegally squatting on private Palestinan land, and killing Palestinains for no other reason than thinking it's their right).

The truth hurts. Stick to the facts and stop the anti-semiticsm stuff.
Of course, any reference to anti-Semitism is code for an urgent need (as you see it) to defend the acts of barbarity of the so-called Jewish state.

Anti-Semitism is a label used to deflect issues from facts and censor discussion and debate.

The term “anti-semitism” loses a bit of its meaning each time someone uses it for a smear, it’s self-defeating and just plain stupid.

You really need to stop. You’re only making Jews look really bad and you’re not helping anything.

It’s not anti-semitism for criticizing Israel or their policies telling people the apartheid, oppression, fanaticism, and occupation are immoral and inhumane.

 

BLUE13326

10:34 AM ET

May 11, 2010

This entire article is a

This entire article is a straw man, a glossy version of a schoolyard taunt.

Whether Goldstone sentenced people to death or torture is a question of fact. This question is entirely independent of whom is accusing him of these past acts.

If he is shown to have engaged in these acts, the next logical question is whether these events in his past should influence our views on his report and views now. Again, this question is entirely independent of whom is accusing him of these past acts.

This grade-school level article can only appeal to those of extremely low intelligence.

 

NORWEGIAN SHOOTER

1:12 PM ET

May 11, 2010

Best blog post headline

EVER! Thank you for standing up to the latest smear campaign. I guess Chait, Goldberg, et al. have lots of dry bagels delivered every few months that they need something to spread on.

 

The Middle East Channel offers unique analysis and insights on this diverse and vital region of more than 400 million.

Read More

Enter your email address to get twice-weekly updates from the Mideast Channel:

Delivered by Constant Contact